yep, I think we need to be more helpful to each other, but if I do find a pic lovely , I am going to continue to say Lovely shot

Snaps I apologise as I once edited one of your pics without asking, a motorcycle pic. so sorryxx

I will try to give more constructive feedback from now on xx I can't get too techy though, as most of you are far more experience than me, so it will be more a gut reaction xx

Seem to remember you turned it from colour to B & W not so bad really as you were saying you though you would like it in B & W, your forgiven and it was Alan's shot anyway I only did the edit

May I say on this non photographic thread I am sorry if I am sometimes posting rubbish, more than usually I mean, I am on some new medication and it is causing me all sorts of problems at the moment but I have to stick with it for a couple of week before they will adjust. Just ignore any off topic and strange wayward posts.

LOL ,that is okay if it was Mr snaps pic

See, now we both know that neither of us like it when someone edits our pics, so we won't do it

So maybe it would be a good idea, if you don't want C&C to remove or not add the little C&C logo

I am going to try to be more constructive from now on x

Snaps don't worry about it xxx I am always going off topic, or making odd comments, and I am not on medication xx

I would love to help sometimes but I always feel I am being rude to someones pic.

Jols do you mind if someone gives you crits? as long as it is constructive? Do you have a problem with someone editing your stuff?

Once again I must agree with Jack's opinions. If I really don't like a photo I don't comment at all. I find saying "good photo" as meaningless as saying ""that photo stinks". I try & make suggestions on how "I" would try & improve a photo. Your interpretation and feelings may be totally different. I get no thrill by flaming a photograph. I've been a photographer for 40 years and learn more every time I shoot. The opinions I get on this forum are valuable to that learning. A lot of suggestions concerning my work are usually spot on. I make changes when I agree and keep things the same when I don't.

I dont mind critique at all [I might not agree though lol]

and I dont mind people editing my pics. Although nobody ever has!

Bob if you find a pic of mine good, please feel free to tell me

I agree Bob, it is more helpful to offer good advice, than just say I don't like it.